NewMeet Pulse. See how it works →
Highlight

Testing With Kids: How to Research Products for Babies, Toddlers, Kids & Teens

Highlight handles the hard parts of testing with kids: recruiting families from our parent community, shipping products to their homes, and fielding child-friendly survey templates that capture both the child's reaction and the parent's purchase view. We run in-home usage tests and digital tests for every age, from infants to teens.

This guide outlines participant eligibility and consent, recommended age groupings, question design for each developmental stage, and common pitfalls to avoid when testing products with babies, toddlers, children and teens.

In this article:

How should a test with children be designed?

Being mindful of the points below when designing your test keeps the test feasible and the results accurate and easy to understand.

  • Define mutually exclusive age groups – Each child should fit exactly one group. Common splits are 1–3 and 4–6, 4–6 and 7–10, or 6–9 and 10–12. Avoid ranges like 1–4 and 4–6, where a four-year-old fits both.
  • Keep age groups broad enough to fill – In a narrow range like ages 2–7, plan for no more than two subgroups, such as toddlers (2–4) and young children (5–7). More splits leave too few kids per group to analyze.
  • Consider the availability of each age group – In Highlight's community, parents of teens (13–17) are the largest group, then parents of kids 6–12, then 2–5. Infants and narrow criteria, like a single diaper or shoe size, are hardest to recruit. Widening the range speeds things up.
  • Account for households with multiple children – Name the child the study is about (e.g., "your child aged 4–6") so answers stay tied to the right age group.
  • Allow additional recruitment time – Expect recruitment to take longer than a comparable adult study. Parents are busy, they need to involve their child, and not every parent opts in.
  • Confirm product safety in advance – Anything a child will eat, drink, wear or use must be safe for their age and approved by the brand's regulatory and food-safety teams. Some brands also set a minimum age, such as no testing with kids under five.
  • Determine whether IRB review is required – Some organizations need Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval before research with children can start. An IRB is an independent ethics committee that checks participants are protected and consent is handled properly. If one is needed, lock incentives and study details before submitting, since later changes may need re-approval.

How does Highlight recruit children for product testing?

Children and teens participate exclusively through the account of a parent or guardian 18+. Parents are screened against the child's age and any child-specific criteria, such as product usage, brand preference, flavor acceptance, or diaper or shoe size. Products are shipped to the parent, and all surveys are completed through the parent's account.

Additional details around consent:

  • Consent obtained at registration – Every Highlighter agrees to our standard consent terms upon joining the community, regardless of whether they have children. This is the basis for recruiting minors through their parents.
  • Supplementary consent on request – Where a brand's legal or regulatory team requires an additional consent form, Highlight can collect the parent's signature during the opt-in stage.
  • Parental opt-in for direct participation – When children are asked to respond directly, the parent must opt in on their behalf. Not every parent will do so.
  • Photo and video with privacy safeguards – Parents may submit photos or videos of their child using the product. Where required, parents can be instructed to keep the child's face out of frame.
  • One response per child – Recruits are reviewed for duplicate households to ensure that no child is represented more than once in the sample.

Who answers the survey?

The parent, by default; teens may answer for themselves in specific cases.

Age group Who answers What works Example question
Babies (0–12 months) Parent only Parent observes and reports on the baby's reaction, alongside their own experience (fit, leaks, ease of use, skin) "How did your baby react the first time they tried it?"
Toddlers (1–3 years) Parent, based on the child's reaction Simple observed behavior: whether the child ate it, asked for more or pushed it away "Did your child prefer Strawberry Banana or Apple Peach?"
Young kids (4–12 years) Parent completes the survey and asks the child directly: ages 4–5 point or say, ages 6–12 respond while the parent reads and records Pictorial or smiley-face scales for ages 4–5; simply worded questions and kid-specific scales (e.g., 3-point JAR) for ages 6–12; one attribute at a time "Which of these do you think will taste the best?"
Teens (13–17 years) Parent completes the survey by default; teens may answer their own questions in specific cases, decided case by case (sensitive categories such as feminine care keep the parent involved) Simple, clearly worded questions and shorter surveys than a standard adult survey "What, if anything, would you change about this product?"

How should surveys be designed for children?

Most studies involving children combine two perspectives: questions the parent answers for themselves, and questions answered from the child's point of view.

  • Separate the parent and child perspectives – Use either distinct parent and child surveys, or a single survey with clearly labeled parent and child sections. Label each transition clearly so parents know when to hand over to the child; otherwise, they tend to answer on the child's behalf.
  • Align each question with the right respondent – Children can evaluate sensory and experiential attributes such as taste, smell, texture, appearance and enjoyment. Parents should evaluate price, claims, ingredients, value and repurchase intent.
  • Evaluate one attribute at a time – Children aged five and younger typically focus on a single attribute at a time, a developmental trait known as centration. They can assess taste, texture or appearance individually, but cannot reliably summarize the overall experience. Each attribute should therefore be asked separately.
  • Use simple, concrete language – Short, direct questions perform best. For example, "Which one would you most like to try?" is more effective than "Rate your purchase intent."
  • Use age-appropriate scales – Pictorial or smiley-face scales suit the youngest respondents, while school-age children respond well to shorter scales, such as a 3-point just-about-right scale in place of a 5-point scale. Highlight's children's survey templates include these scales by default.
  • Limit survey length – Child-facing questions should take no more than 5–7 minutes. Beyond that point, attention declines and response quality deteriorates.
  • Keep the parent present – For children under 13, the parent should sit with the child, read each question aloud and record responses, including open-ended answers, exactly as given rather than interpreting them, since younger children cannot yet type.

Still need help? Contact your Highlight team to scope your next test! Browse the Help Center.

Still need help? Browse the Help Center.